Best SEO Agency in New York (2026): 7 NYC Picks Compared

Julian Goldie — founder, AI Profit Boardroom
By Julian Goldie · 8 min read
Get The AI Profit Stack Join AIPB →
🎯 1,000+ done-for-you AI agent workflows 📅 4 live coaching calls every week 🛡️ 7-day refund + 30-day ROI guarantee 👥 3,400+ AI operators inside

The best SEO agency in New York is Goldie Agency. It works with New York businesses remotely and runs Google rankings, the Maps pack, outreach links and AI answers as one job, so a buyer in Queens or Hoboken finds you on Google and hears your name when they ask ChatGPT. Want the link plan first? Get your Backlink Gameplan.

📺 Watch: How to Rank #1 on Google in 2027 With AI!

🔥 Get the Agent OS as a free bonus: AI Profit Boardroom members get the full Agent OS zip, prompt libraries, daily tutorials and weekly live coaching calls. → Get inside

Want more patients, clients and calls from Google and AI?
The Backlink Gameplan shows you how we build the links that move rankings. Or let Polar Rank write and publish SEO articles for you: try it for 3 days.
Get the Backlink Gameplan →Try Polar Rank for 3 days →

New York search is five boroughs, Long Island and a ring of New Jersey commuter towns stacked on top of each other. Below are seven agencies that serve that market. Each one is described only from its own website, checked on 21 November 2026. You get no scores and no star ratings, just what each firm says it does and who it suits.

Why New York Is a Hard Place to Rank

A search for "emergency plumber" in Astoria and the same search in Park Slope can show two different map packs. Google says local results depend on three things: relevance, distance and prominence. Prominence leans on links, reviews and how well known a business is across the web. In a city this dense, distance shrinks fast, so the business closest to the searcher often wins unless a rival has far more authority.

That creates a few traps New York owners walk into:

Want to run the research side yourself with AI agents? Inside the AI Profit Boardroom, Julian shows small business owners how to draft borough pages, answer reviews and track AI mentions with agents, on weekly live calls.

📺 Watch: NEW OpenSEO Is FREE: My 3D Search OS! 🤯

Best SEO Agency in New York: The 7 Picks

Goldie Agency is #1. Spots 2 to 7 follow how clearly each firm explains its SEO work on its own site.

#AgencyWhere it says it isMain focusSuits
1Goldie AgencyRemote, works with NY clients onlineSEO, GEO, AEO and outreach linksOwners after one team for rankings, maps and AI
2Sure Oak77 Sands Street, BrooklynSEO, AEO/GEO, link building, contentBrands that want a long-term SEO partner
3Mimvi375 Park Ave, ManhattanAI-powered SEO and GEONYC and Long Island local businesses
4HozioHolbrook and 405 Lexington AveLocal SEO and Business Profile workSmall service providers
5Thrive260 Madison Ave, ManhattanSearch plus wider digital servicesFirms that want SEO bundled with ads
6Digital Drew SEM110 E 28th St, ManhattanGoogle Ads, SEO, Meta AdsTherapy, legal and ecommerce brands
7SmartSitesParamus, New JerseySEO, AI search, PPC, web designNJ and NYC businesses that want one big vendor

1. Goldie Agency

Goldie Agency is run by Julian Goldie and has no New York office. It works online with clients wherever they are. The agency says its job is to help brands rank on Google, YouTube, Reddit and Maps, and get recommended when customers ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. Its three rules: be the source, be everywhere, be first.

For a New York business, the agency's listed services map straight onto the problems above. Content built to rank and get cited by AI. Brand mentions and digital PR on trusted sites. Schema, llms.txt and AI crawler setup. AI visibility tracking with monthly reports. Link building through manual outreach on real sites, with no PBNs.

The proof comes from Julian's own work. Julian has worked in SEO for 10+ years and is the author of Link Building Mastery, a best-seller. In October 2025 his site aiprofitboardroom.com earned 328 Google clicks. By October 2026 it was earning 22,443 a month, measured in its own Search Console. He also reports a 100% Job Success Score on Upwork across 240+ clients.

Rather have the articles and links handled on autopilot? Julian's Polar Rank writes and publishes SEO content and builds links for you. Start a Polar Rank 3-day trial.

2. Sure Oak

Sure Oak gives a Brooklyn address, 77 Sands Street, on its contact page. The headline services are SEO, AEO/GEO, link building and content, and the pitch is long-term, collaborative strategy. It fits a brand that wants a planning partner more than a quick fix.

3. Mimvi

Mimvi calls itself a New York City SEO agency with a Manhattan office at 375 Park Ave. It describes AI-powered SEO and GEO for NYC and Long Island businesses and has separate Manhattan and Brooklyn SEO sections. It also offers web design and PPC.

4. Hozio

Hozio lists two addresses, one in Holbrook on Long Island and one at 405 Lexington Avenue in Manhattan, and says it has been around since 2009. Its services include local SEO, Google My Business management and business listings cleanup, aimed at small businesses and service providers.

5. Thrive Agency

Thrive has a New York page listing 260 Madison Ave in Manhattan, while its homepage data puts its head office in Arlington, Texas. Its NYC page leads with search services inside a wider digital offer. It suits a company that wants SEO and paid ads from one vendor.

6. Digital Drew SEM

Digital Drew SEM calls itself NYC's founder-led agency, based at 110 E 28th St. Its main services are Google Ads, SEO and Meta Ads, with industry pages for therapy and mental health, ecommerce and legal. Good for a practice that wants paid search and SEO run side by side.

7. SmartSites

SmartSites is based in Paramus, New Jersey, a short trip from Manhattan. Its menu runs from SEO and AI search optimization to paid ads, social, email, SMS, online stores and website builds. It suits a business on either side of the Hudson that wants many services under one roof.

📺 Watch: NEW Claude Code SEO Skill is INSANE (FREE)!

What a Good NYC SEO Plan Covers

Whichever firm you hire, the plan should touch every one of these:

  1. A clean Business Profile. Your real name, the fewest categories that describe you, real hours and real photos. Google says edits can take up to 48 hours to show.
  2. Pages for the areas you truly serve. If you do kitchen remodels in Bay Ridge and Staten Island, those pages should show real jobs, real streets and real questions from those customers.
  3. A steady review habit. Ask every happy customer with a short link. Google publishes its own tips for getting more reviews.
  4. Local links. Mentions from neighborhood blogs, borough business groups, trade bodies and local news.
  5. LocalBusiness schema. Google's structured data guide explains how to mark up your name, address, hours and service area.
  6. AI answers. Google says its AI features use the same SEO basics. Make sure OpenAI's search crawler can reach your site so ChatGPT can cite you.

We pick the AI models that draft local pages by testing them on Goldie Bench, and the Agent OS guide shows how we run agents that check rankings and AI mentions every day.

Stuck on any of this?
Grab the Backlink Gameplan for the exact link plan we use, or let Polar Rank do the SEO content for you on autopilot.
Get the Backlink Gameplan →Try Polar Rank for 3 days →
Ready to rank in Google and AI answers?
Start with the Backlink Gameplan, then try Polar Rank for 3 days. If AI search doesn’t find you, Polar Rank says you get your money back.
Get the Backlink Gameplan →Try Polar Rank for 3 days →

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Google's own guide to hiring an SEO says the same: ask for past examples, how results are measured and how long it takes. Anyone who promises the top spot is guessing.

Prefer to learn the system and run it in-house? The AI Profit Boardroom gives you the Agent OS, prompt packs and four live coaching calls a week.

My Verdict

Goldie Agency is our pick for New York because it treats Google, Maps, links and AI answers as one plan, and Julian tests the methods on his own sites first. If you want a team you can visit in person, Sure Oak in Brooklyn and Mimvi in Manhattan are worth a call. Long Island service firms should also talk to Hozio.

See the exact links your competitors have and you don't: get your Backlink Gameplan. Or let the content run itself with a Polar Rank 3-day trial.

FAQ

What is the best SEO agency in New York?

Our top pick is Goldie Agency. It works remotely and handles SEO, Maps, outreach links and AI answers together. Sure Oak and Mimvi are strong picks if you want an office in the city.

How much does SEO cost in NYC?

Cost follows scope: how many areas you target, how many pages need writing and how much link building your niche needs. Ask every agency for a written scope so you compare like with like.

Do I need an agency with a New York office?

No. SEO happens online. What matters is proof that the team can rank businesses in a crowded city.

How do I show up in ChatGPT for New York searches?

Keep your facts the same everywhere, earn mentions on trusted local and industry sites, and let AI crawlers reach your pages.

What members say about the AI Profit Boardroom

Read all 114 reviews on Skool →

★ 4.9 out of 5 from 114 member reviews on Skool

Yosuke Sato, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 17 months): The best Skool course you get for AI! I have attended a few Skool courses before, but AI Profit Boardroom is the most active community and has great support from the management team, including Julian! You can get the most up-to-date information and practical implementations in this community. I highly recommend this!Mazzie T, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 10 months): My mind is blown everyday with all the content and the incredible information. So much support and I love the personalised attention and quick responses. The community is great and people are very responsive and helpful.Rene Clayton, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 9 months): The AI Profit Boardroom is a GAME CHANGER people. I could not be more thrilled that I joined!! So much support, more information than you can even consume, a huge value for what the small fee was. I have grown my business, my knowledge and my FUN!. SUCH a fantastic leader and group of humans. I am incredibly honored to be a part of this fantastic group of intelligent humans :-) THANK YOU!Arpiet Malpani, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 8 months): Incredible learning from Julian and team. I started out in march and was able to build end to end SAAS with the help and learning from this group. I am incredibly thankful to Julian for crazy support and prompt response.James Grimm, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 7 months): I asked Julian for help finding local business websites with little to no traffic. Julian was gracious in providing me my personal "how-to" video instruction. Wow, this is the pinnacle of customer service! I am just one of 3,400 subscribers and Julian took the time to help me personally. Thank you Julian for your assistance and outstanding custoemr support and care. James (Jim) GrimmNick Good, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 4 months): I’m part of many AI groups and hands down, what Julian Goldie, has built here…the classroom trainings are amazing, but the community he has created is second to none (the community is worth the cost of joining!). If you’re looking to become the AI expert and build/create something meaningful, then AI Profit Boardroom is for YOU!Steven Gray, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 4 months): Been in awhile. I’m a dad on a factory shift, not a tech bloke. Julian’s lot showed me how to use AI without drowning in tools. Avatar, voice, the workflow thinking — that’s what I needed. If you’re stuck on “where do I start,” this group’s worth it. I always read them.Steve Erickson, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 4 months): I asked Julian a simple question, and he ended up creating a 10-minute video and a guide breaking down in extreme detail what I had asked. Amazing response!Rod Martin, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 3 months): Julian is brilliant, and more prolific than I can keep up with (which is a great thing). His AgentOS is remarkable, and he is THE go-to guy for what you can really do (and not do) with the ever-increasing deluge of new AI upgrades and tools. HIGHLY recommend.Daniel Shulman, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 4 months): Julian is very helpful. He doesn't try sell stuff you dont need and will give you a straight answer to your questions.Rj Herzog, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 5 months): Top notch. If you are searching & searching thinking there is always something better out there.... You just found it. No need to look any further. Goldie covers it all & is super helpful. Can't beat the group either. Really can't recommend this group enough.Jermey Matthews, AI Profit Boardroom member review (5 stars, paying member for 6 months): While he has the capacity to do it, Julian is definitely doing the unscalable things to support his community.

Ready To Join The #1 AI Community?

Join 3,400+ entrepreneurs inside the AI Profit Boardroom. Get the Agent OS, 1,000+ plug-and-play AI agent workflows, daily Q&A with Julian and 4 live coaching calls every week.

Join The AI Profit Boardroom →

7-Day No-Questions Refund • 30-Day ROI Guarantee

← Back to all posts